The high level paybacks of outsourcing IT services are often well-known within the IT industry. Even so, many clients do not fully understand “why” and “how” an outsourcing agreement can provide these potential benefits. Those who do understand the benefits may not understand the risks that must be managed in order to realize those benefits. Understanding theprobable risks will allow you to make a better informed sourcing decision.Even though the benefits of outsourcing are fairly well-known, it is worth summarizing them for reference.
Reduced Cost
Companies that provide IT outsourcing services function in a highly competitive marketplace. This market pressure, coupled with the scale of capabilities, abundance of lower-cost (but highly skilled) labor and investments in productivity tools and processes, means a provider can more than likely deliver services at a much lower price than you can do on your own. Additionally, you will improve your ability to achieve year-over year savings, as annual reductions are often documented in an outsourcing agreement.
Improved Quality
Outsourcing vendors are motivated to improve the quality of your operations. Outsourcing providers have invested billions of dollars to build the tools and processes they use to deliver IT services to clients, and they use these investments to differentiate their ability to provide high quality services at comparatively lower costs. The cost models typically used by providers will assume some annual reduction in resources (and therefore costs) based on the quality improvements they assume they can make. Moreover, a market-based outsourcing contract will drive adherence to well-defined service levels, some of which are expected to improve over time. As the famous saying goes,“what gets measured gets managed.”
Ability to Redeploy Resources
Gradually this is becoming one of the more important factors influencing sourcing decisions. The challenge many IT departments face is how to free up some of their most knowledgeable people to workon initiatives that will truly add value to the business. Some of these people become
“superstars” over time, and are continually pulled into operational issues which reduce their ability to drive strategic change. Without a significant event like a new outsourcing agreement, it can be hard to overcome the organizational inactivity that keeps these people locked into their current role. As quality improvements are made and the provider becomes skilled at addressing operational issues, these people can be redeployed into higher value planning, engineering or development work, and you get the added benefit that they are still in the organization “just in case” their skills are needed.
Improved Delivery Capability
Procuring managed services from an outsourcing provider, if done well and if structured by a market-based agreement, encourages a higher level of performance related to services, service levels, innovation and process maturity. Creating and negotiating an outsourcing contract requires you to spend time articulating the specific services to be performed and how those services will be measured. Integrating your processes with those of another company requires a higher level of process discipline
Risks
The probable risks of outsourcing are not nearly as well-understood as the potential benefits. An important observation is that many times clients develop risk mitigation strategies that are almost solely based on technical risk. Understandably, there are concerns and issues that need to be worked through in every outsourcing relationship. Issues such as connectivity, knowledge transfer, dearth of certain skills, migrating environments, etc… are important and need to be addressed.
Absence of Communication
The importance of a detailed and managed communications plan cannot be over-emphasized. This is about ensuring your retained employees, your non-retained employees, your employees who are transferring to the provider, your executives, your stakeholders, your leadership team and yes even your potential new provider are being told what they need to know when they need to know it. Without a structured communications plan and process that explains what is happening and why, there will be voids that will be filled with misinformation and a reluctance to change. This can lead to unplanned employee turnover, missed transition plans, and a lack of understanding and buy-in from the consumers of IT services. Actively pursue ways to keep your provider informed (even during the contract negotiation phase), not just from a transition perspective but also to keep them fully apprised of the activities and objectives of the business. This will allow them to better understand your requirements and to deliver the best solution possible.
Your lack of ability to Change Behavior
The IT leadership team in place today quite probably became successful through their ability to manage specific technology and people. However, a significantly different set of skills is required to successfully manage an outsourcing relationship. Leaders must learn to handle expectations and outcomes and let the outsourcing provider manage how that work gets done. This is done by managing relationships, governance processes, status reporting, issue tracking, prioritizing, service level management, and process discipline. Unfortunately it can be difficult for some people to move from one paradigm to another. If these types of leaders cannot change but remain in a position to direct the provider, they become a source of friction in the relationship and can keep you from receiving the maximum value from your outsourcing provider. Make sure your leaders have the right skills to manage an outsourcing relationship, or substitute them with ones who do.
Loss of Business Knowledge
It was somewhat normal for companies to outsource practically all of their services to a provider, often time only leaving a CIO and a couple of executives in place to manage the relationship. Unfortunately, companies understood that they had outsourced too much, and by doing so had lost much of their “tribal knowledge” so they struggled to stay aligned to the business. The good news is that arrangement is rarely used anymore, and companies now realize they must retain a sufficient level of strategic resources to manage the outsourcing relationship, manage the relationships with the business, maintain overall accountability for delivery, and to set overall direction and priorities. Also, as you develop your transition plans you must address how knowledge will be transferred to the provider. In some cases it is primarily done through the transfer of certain subject matter experts to the provider, while in many cases it is really dependent on the system documentation and training sessions used to share knowledge with the provider. As you develop transition plans and design your retained organization, ensure that you fully comprehend the need to build and retain key business knowledge.
Unclear Expectations
There are hardly ever cases where an outsourcing provider does not and cannot provide the services they committed to in the outsourcing contract. However, there is always a minor risk that something was not thoroughly understood and documented during the negotiation phase, and that for some reason cannot be effectively supported in the new agreement. What can you do? As they say, the best form of defence is a good offense, and there are several means you can design into the outsourcing contract to protect yourself in these cases. For example, make sure to require a assurance to follow a defined set of industry standards (e.g., ITIL, CMMi) so that services are more easily transferrable to other providers if required. Make sure the agreement is flexible enough to allow for some change in scope without cessation penalties. Define a strong, market-based service level contract that defines remedies and penalties, and define and put into practice a governance process that ensures delivery and relationship issues are quickly escalated to the right executive levels for resolution. From a vendor management perspective, you may also want to consider a multi-vendor strategy that maintains some competitive tension while also providing you with a “hot backup” provider in the event that certain services are not being delivered as expected.
Business Case not achieved
At the end of the day, the goal of an outsourcing relationship is to achieve the defined sourcing objectives while meeting the business case upon which the decision was made. Oftentimes, the focus after agreement is signed is only on the technical portion of the transition of services, and it becomes almost impossible as the months go by to track performance back to the business case. Even when the business case is tracked and managed, it is found that the original business case was inaccurate or inadequate, and therefore the actual costs are higher than expected while the corresponding overall savings are less than expected. The best way to mitigate this situation is to ensure the business case is thorough, comprehends all expected investments, savings, and new charges, and is developed with a level of detail that can survive inspection from the CFO and board.
It should include assumed ramp up of services, ramp down of retained organization expenses, one-time costs for transition, legal fees, advisory fees and the like, retaining of certain resources, appropriate contingencies, expected changes due to growth and scope changes, COLA impacts, and so on. The business case should be updated periodically and reported against the baseline business case to identify any significant variances.
Conclusion
While benefits of outsourcing IT services are fairly well-known, many clients do not fully understand the risks that must be managed in order to achieve these benefits. Prior to finalizing a decision to outsource, make sure to think about how you will communicate with key stakeholders, change the behaviors of your leadership team to manage an outsourcing relationship, retain the required level of business knowledge, clarify and thoroughly document expectations, and develop and manage a solid business case. By doing so, you will make a improved informed sourcing decision and will be better prepared to understand the benefits that an outsourcing relationship can offer.